Properly chided, Grimbeorn sat back down as he found he was standing while questioning the wizard.  "I know naught of the way of Wizards and Elves, but still would've thought that power enough to siege would be power enough to destroy.  Pardon me my rash words."

Excellent posts, Matt!  

The irony of it is that in the appendix, Galadriel does just that during the War of the Ring. This articles asks why didn't she just do it the first time...

you gotta love Tolkien for his inconsistencies and contradictions! (hence my dialogue from Gandalf stating that those powers don't exist anymore in Middle-earth, but then that Galadriel will need to reserve her powers)  

QuoteSeveral strongholds of elves and men are besieged while Frodo and Sam are trudging laboriously through Mordor to Mount Doom. In particular, Lothlórien repels three such assaults before Galadriel and Celeborn finally lead a counter-offensive against Dol Guldur.

"...the assaults were driven back; and when the Shadow passed, Celeborn came forth and led the host of Lórien over Anduin in many boats. They took Dol Guldur, and Galadriel threw down its walls and laid bare its pits, and the forest was cleansed." Appendix B, Lord of the Rings.

That last sentence has often puzzled; people wonder exactly how Galadriel might have accomplished such a task. More, why is she doing now what ought to have been accomplished when the White Council drove Sauron from Dol Guldur years before?

http://www.theonering.net/torwp/2013/04/20/70929-dol-guldurs-destruction-why-galadriel-succeeds-where-the-white-council-fails/

Gandalf's smile returned, "No harm done, Master Beorning! Now come... let us partake in a meal and decide who will be taking this journey; then all that needs done is preparations."

Quote from: tomcat on Sep 02, 2015, 04:33 PM Excellent posts, Matt! 

The irony of it is that in the appendix, Galadriel does just that during the War of the Ring. This articles asks why didn't she just do it the first time...

you gotta love Tolkien for his inconsistencies and contradictions! (hence my dialogue from Gandalf stating that those powers don't exist anymore in Middle-earth, but then that Galadriel will need to reserve her powers) 

QuoteSeveral strongholds of elves and men are besieged while Frodo and Sam are trudging laboriously through Mordor to Mount Doom. In particular, Lothlórien repels three such assaults before Galadriel and Celeborn finally lead a counter-offensive against Dol Guldur.

"...the assaults were driven back; and when the Shadow passed, Celeborn came forth and led the host of Lórien over Anduin in many boats. They took Dol Guldur, and Galadriel threw down its walls and laid bare its pits, and the forest was cleansed." Appendix B, Lord of the Rings.

That last sentence has often puzzled; people wonder exactly how Galadriel might have accomplished such a task. More, why is she doing now what ought to have been accomplished when the White Council drove Sauron from Dol Guldur years before?

http://www.theonering.net/torwp/2013/04/20/70929-dol-guldurs-destruction-why-galadriel-succeeds-where-the-white-council-fails/

She no longer needed to hide the ring and was willing to use its power.

Abashed by the wizards' response to his assumption, Arbogast sits in silence as Grimbeorn and Gandalf debate.  Nazgul, Angmar, ancient elves... these things are beyond the little he has seen of Middle Earth, and the sudden realisation of its breath and history unsettle the young Woodman. 

Still, in challenge lies opportunity.  If Radaghast is to accompany the fellowship to Dol Guldur, then Arbogast resolves to learn all he can of these things. 

In the meantime, he has counsel to offer.  For few, even if the Wise, know Mirkwood as he does.  He draws rough maps upon the wizard's table in charcoal from the fire, and speculates on where food and water might be found. 

"To Dol Guldur itself I have never been, but I am certain that I can scout the way."


  So, I'm putting Arbogast's hand up as the fellowship's scout, for Journey system purposes (he would also make a half-decent look-out man).  I'll also rely on his Mirkwood Lore for a bonus die, rather than his rather dismal Lore skill.

Esgalwen listened intently as the Grey Wizard made his arguments. While she felt no closer to knowing the details of their mission, she felt more confident than when she first spoke – a Wizard, and Radagast no less, in their company was a boon for sure. Even without him, though, looking around at her companions, the Ranger felt a comforting peace. Here were brave souls, indeed. She had witnessed firsthand their fierce courage and loyalty. The Wizard himself had said they possessed strength, did he not.

"I will go," Esgalwen stated with grace-filled confidence. "I have wandered the lands near our destination and heard the whispers of many folk who have seen it with their eyes. If you will allow me, it would be my honour to guide the company to the gates."

  Esgalwen's travel score is 3, which is the best of the group present, I think... and better than any of her skills in any of the other roles... not sure if Adventurous (confidence in her ability to lead) or Folk Lore (heard stories from Mogdred and his men) might help her as well?

Anyway... if needed here is Esgalwen's Lore roll for the Journey Advantages:

Lore TN: 14
  +

  BOO!    I think I just failed that because of the feat die rolling an 11 (eye of Sauron)... not sure if maybe I can use Folk Lore (she has been listening to the men of the Southern Vale) to at least gain a success?

Hopefully, she rolls better when guiding the company!!

Those who have grown up in the these woods and know its nature should be the ones to lead us into the south. I am not much of a hunter, as you know. But I have keen eyes and am little noticed, so I can keep watch as we proceed.

  Bandy volunteers to be the look out. His Awareness is about the same as everyone else's. He will also roll for travel advantage.

"You need not ask if I will join, for who else is there to look out for you all? Orcs, spiders, whatever may be there will flee before us or be crushed," said the bold Beorning, standing confident once again. "I fear not the road that lies ahead or its destination."

  Beorn can act as hunter for advantages...
 

Rolled 1d12 : 5, total 5

 

Rolled 3d6 : 1, 6, 3, total 10

Thanks, guys! I am glad you took the initiative to assign yourself to the positions for journeys. I meant to ask you to do this in my last post, but I forgot.

Ayrn - I went ahead and allowed your traits to give you the ordinary success.

Results of Lore tests for Journey

PC	Advantage	Position
Arbogast	1 die	scout
Esgalwen	1 die	guide
Bandy	1 die	look-out
Grimbeorn	2 dice	hunter

Haven't heard anything about Rorin in a while - you still playing, disench4nted?

Stefan, let me know where you want to fit in on the journey.

I will have a post up in a bit.

I have another thing to do for you guys...

The Adventuring Phase we are starting now in the Darkening of Mirkwood campaign is actually the 4th - but I merged the first and second together (meeting the Wizard's Man and the Folk-moot) into one chapter, and the third (the Questing Beast) was kind of dumb and so I ignored it (although some of the details will still happen in-story, just not by your hands). SO...that means we have missed out on two Fellowship Phases and the chance to earn AP and XP.

To keep the PC's growing at the right pace and to be able to handle the progressive challenges - I am awarding to each PC 7 AP and 8 XP to spend before we go any further in this chapter. Make sense? I know this is relatively the same amount you earned for the prior Fellowship Phase, but that phase actually covered two adventure phases and so only one was not roleplayed.

If you feel this is not enough, please chime in - I am open to your ideas.

As before, list your use of the points in a post on this thread. Once everyone is done, I will continue our story.

Thanks!

  Hey Doug, pages 212/213 in the One Ring Roleplaying book have the following guidelines listed for AP XP advancement:

The guideline is that each Adventure Phase takes about 3 sessions of play on average.

For AP advancement, the suggested rate is 4+ per session... or 12+ per Adventure Phase.
For XP advancement, the suggested rate is 2 per session plus 1 or 2 more per Adventure.. or 6-8 XP per Adventure Phase.

So, if what you are saying is that we have advanced through 3 adventures so far (2 combined and 1 skipped), the guideline would be 36+ AP and 18-24 XP... minus what we were already awarded (6 AP and 8 XP)... would be about 30 APs and 10-16 XP.

That sounds like alot but really isn't when you consider the costs to increase skills and wisdom/valour. 30 AP would go pretty fast... Esgalwen could raise 3 common skills from 1 to 2 and 1 favoured skill from 1 to 2

16 XP maybe goes a bit further... Esgalwen could raise her bow skill from 1 to 3, and gain another Wisdom point (or 2 Valour points)

Anyway, I suppose it depends on the challenges that the next adventure phase will bring. I haven't read through the DoM book, so I can't offer any wisdom on that.



 

Quote from: Posterboy on Sep 03, 2015, 06:09 PM [maths snipped]

Anyway, I suppose it depends on the challenges that the next adventure phase will bring. I haven't read through the DoM book, so I can't offer any wisdom on that.

I confess, I've read The Darkening of Mirkwood cover to cover, though not since it came out, and certainly not since we started playing.  While I will never complain about free XP, those of you who have played your share of computer games will be familiar with the idea that any time you're presented with a sudden windfall, it's a sign that you're about to get your arse kicked. 

ANYWAY!  Let's proceed with the figures from Doug, and I'll adjust later if any adjustment is necessary.  I think, given how frequently Arbogast has been trudging back and forth through the Narrows of the Forest, bumping his Travel skill up from 1 to 2 (spending my saved AP from last session) is warranted.  I'll also increase his Long Hafted Axe from 2 to 3, because there's spiders in them thar trees. 

Thanks Doug. I was not expecting any APs and XPs at this point so they are most welcome.

Bandy will spend 6XPs to increase his bow skill to 3. He'll bank the remaining 4. And since he has been cutting trees and building muscle to impress Esgalwen, he'll spend 8 APs to increase Athletics to 2, which leaves him 1 AP for later.

For what it is worth, here is a link to a Cubicle 7 TOR discussion on the awarding of AP and XP and it seems that 6-8 XP per adventure is pretty standard whether in face-to-face or PbP games.